• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Menlo Pizza

At Menlo Pizza, located in Edison, NJ, we believe in crafting exceptional pizza and sandwiches that delight every palate. Founded with a passion for authentic flavors, our cozy, family-owned establishment offers a range of dishes, from classic Jersey slices to inventive hot subs and wraps. Each pizza boasts a perfect balance of sauce and cheese, complemented by a crispy yet tender crust. Loved by locals, our inviting atmosphere and friendly service create a memorable dining experience. With many vegetarian options and convenient catering services, Menlo Pizza is dedicated to serving delicious meals for lunch, dinner, or any gathering. Come taste the difference!

Menlo Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Rafael G.
Rafael G.

I just happen to stumble into this pizzeria by chance and I have to say. WOW!!! I just had the bacon ranch slice and a white pizza slice. Has to be one of the best bacon pizza I've ever had. Every bite had bacon on it. The slice was a good size, just big enough to enjoy and have room for another. I must say that I'll be back to try the other plates they have here. Highly recommend! Server was super nice as well. 5 out of 5 stars.

Ketki P.
Ketki P.

Marguerita, plain, and onions and peppers are the pies that we get. They are all great!! A classic, what you would expect, Jersey slice pizza!and everyone there is very nice too.

Erik D.
Erik D.

Best pizza in Northern Middlesex County and one of the best in CNJ, where I've lived for the past 44 years. Perfect cheese/sauce ratio (not overloaded with cheese) and the sauce is perfectly flavored and the crust is just right, with very little slice "flop." Great garlic knots too. We get pizza there at least twice a month. Nothing fancy about the place, which looks like it probably did in the 70s, but for a pizza place (and most restaurants), I don't really give much of a crap about setting - the food is all that matters as long as the service is at least decent and they're very friendly there.

Assisi G.
Assisi G.

We got a pepperoni and the works and dined in. Pizzas were good; the crust had the right thickness/crunch. But the works only had 5 toppings. Five stars anyways b/c service was decent and no complaints, especially when our tummies were hungry.

Jamilli H.
Jamilli H.

Pizza taste is so mind blowing every spice from the sauce to the toppings to the dough crunchy& yummy. Family owned wonderful feels like you're in a little Cozy restaurant pizzeria in Italy. They also deliver if you're ever having a party at Menlo Park now thank you for being such a finale, outstanding business.

Mike D.
Mike D.

Terrific service & location but most of all THIS IS GREAT PIE. There's been a big drop off in good pizzerias over the last few years as the old generation retires or passes and the kids have moved on to law, medicine, or other professions. Food service is a tough bloody business: long hours, no paid time off, and cash to watch... but it's practically recession-proof! I hope that the next generation takes on this shop. If you're looking for ambiance and white glove service, go to a sit down restaurant. If you're looking for great pizza and quick, friendly service, GO HERE.

Rafael A.
Rafael A.

Just great pizza. Deliciously seasoned and cooked to perfection. Exceptional service, Thom the pizza genius was so friendly! I was in the mood for pizza but they have an extensive menu. Going to try a pasta dish on my next visit if I can resist reordering the dynamite pizza. It will be tough!!! A must if you want delicious pizza!!!

Gregg J.
Gregg J.

Wow! I just stopped in for a couple of slices and they certainly did not disappoint! Very good pie here and friendly service. I shall return when in the area again.

Jeff T.
Jeff T.

The thin crust pizza choices were hot and ready to choose from. Mushroom and chicken parmesan were fantastic. Just what I needed for a mid day treat. They were welcoming and friendly. Thank you!

Mike C.
Mike C.

Was in Newark and needed to head south late on a Sunday night and wanted to grab some Jersey pizza on the way home-this place had good reviews and they lived up to the standard reviewers set. Called to order pick up, just a large cheese, and picked up on the way. Was greeted cordially upon entering, simple transaction, and was thanked by all three working behind counter and in kitchen. Restaurant was mostly empty with only a couple of diners-place was a little outdated, but that added to the charm. Pizza was good, typical NY style. Thin as expected, cheese was decent, sauce could have been a bit sweeter. Crust was about average. Bottom line is I would return if in the area again-I'd rate 7.1 out of 10.

Location

  • Menlo Pizza
    170 Lafayette Ave, Edison, NJ 08837 Hotline: (732) 548-0660

Introducing Menlo Pizza: Your Go-To Destination for Delicious Pizza and More

Located in the heart of Edison, NJ, at 170 Lafayette Ave, Menlo Pizza has carved out a niche for itself as a beloved pizza joint, offering a diverse menu that caters to every taste. With a reputation as a casual eatery that welcomes families, friends, and groups alike, Menlo Pizza is not just about pizza; it’s an experience centered on community and flavor.

The moment you step into Menlo Pizza, you’re met with a warm, welcoming atmosphere, perfect for lunch, dinner, and even celebrations with loved ones. The friendly staff is committed to providing excellent service, ensuring that each visit is memorable.

Menu Highlights:

  • Delectable Pizza Varieties: Customers rave about the mouthwatering options, from the classic Margherita to out-of-this-world offerings like the bacon ranch and white pizza, each slice bursting with flavor.
  • Hot Subs and Wraps: The Balsamic Chicken Pita and Buffalo Chicken Wrap become quick favorites, showcasing the creative flair of the kitchen.
  • Comfort Food: Indulge in classic favorites like Chicken Gyros and Chicken Quesadillas, providing something for everyone, including a range of vegetarian choices.

What sets Menlo Pizza apart is the perfect balance of quality ingredients and genuine attention to detail. Customers have applauded the cheese and sauce ratio—just enough flavor without overwhelming the palate. The crust is another highlight, delivering a satisfying crunch that complements the toppings beautifully. As Erik D. notes, it’s about the simplicity of great food in a no-frills environment, a sentiment echoed by many who frequent the establishment.

The ambiance strikes a balance between casual and friendly, making it a great spot for families and larger gatherings. With amenities such as outdoor seating, on-site parking, and the convenience of takeout and delivery services, Menlo Pizza checks all the right boxes for a memorable dining experience.

Whether you’re looking to indulge with a slice of pizza, enjoy a hearty sub, or share some garlic knots, Menlo Pizza invites you to create your own culinary adventure. As Jamilli H. passionately states, visiting feels like stepping into a cozy Italian pizzeria, where every dish is crafted with love.

Visit Menlo Pizza today, and discover why it’s regarded as one of the best pizza spots in Northern Middlesex County. You won’t just leave with a full stomach; you’ll leave with a smile.

Phone Number: (732) 548-0660